| Reviewed on 2005-04-08 |
| Rated | R |
| Received |   [2.5] out of 4 stars |
| Genre | Action / Crime / Drama / Thriller |
| Website | http://www.sincitythemovie.com |
|
| And You Thought Gotham City Was Bad...
When I saw “Sin City” I was not overly impressed. The
film is based on a series of graphic novels by
writer/artist Frank Miller. The trailers say "heroes
will rise." The only person in the whole movie worthy
of that title is Bruce Willis' cop.
Lots of people will be put off by the three not quite
interrelated story lines. Others will be puzzled about
the meta-human powers exhibited by various characters.
No super-heroes here. In fact the only ones who wear
spandex are the heavily armed prostitutes who control
one section of the deeply corrupt city.
Fifteen years ago Warren Beatty's “Dick Tracy” paid
homage to the four color printing process by only
using a few primary colors on screen. “Sin City”
essentially stays in black & white unless they want to
throw blood in your face. Compared to “Sin City” the
heavily color processed "Sky Captain & the World of
Tomorrow" is a 1950's Technicolor western.
I'm no fan of Frank Miller's comics work. However I'm
glad that for once it appears that the creator of a
comics based property got to help bring his own vision
to the screen. That doesn't mean I have to like the
finished product. I didn't care for his writing on
“Robocop 3” either.
However, I'm only one opinion. 'Pokey' is an on-line
friend whose views I respect. He likes the graphic
novels. I hope he doesn't mind me borrowing his post
to a forum we belong to. On opening day he told us, “I
went and saw an early matinée of Sin City and enjoyed
it very much for what it was, a Frank Miller comic
book. 3 stars out of 4 and 4 stars for the Mickey
Rourke segment. Not for kids and not a date movie
unless the girl is a comic book fan. A half a notch
below the Kill Bill films but very much worth seeing.
Lot's of graphic novel violence.” He's got that right.
Be careful who you take to “Sin City.”
|
|